News

Training

Dumbbell bench press and dumbbell fly built similar chest muscle in a 10-week trial

By Monica O'Reilly

Published · Updated

A person performs a dumbbell chest press lying back on a stability ball
A person performs a dumbbell chest press on a stability ball. Illustrative stock photo. Photo: PTPioneer, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/)

What the trial tested

Twenty-six recreationally trained young men were allocated to dumbbell bench press (DBP) or dumbbell fly (DFLY). They had an average of 3.3 years of training experience, with a standard deviation of 3.1 years. Each group trained twice weekly for 10 weeks.

Weekly set numbers were individualised to each participant’s previous chest training volume. Researchers measured pectoralis major muscle thickness by ultrasound before and after training at medial (30%), intermediate (50%) and lateral (70%) sites.

Similar growth across the measured sites

Muscle thickness increased over time, with a main effect of time (p < 0.05). There was no time-by-group interaction at the medial site (p = 0.500), intermediate site (p = 0.864), lateral site (p = 0.720), or for the sum of sites (p = 0.985).

Both exercises produced similar whole and regional pectoralis major hypertrophy in this trial. The authors conclude that coaches can choose either exercise according to preference and goals when working with recreationally trained men.

What it means for recreational lifters

Recreational lifters can choose a press or fly according to preference and training goals. As exercise background, a dumbbell press also trains the triceps and shoulders and allows heavier loads. The trial’s muscle growth findings give either exercise a place in chest training.

Limits that matter

The findings cover 10 weeks in recreationally trained young men. The outcome was muscle thickness measured by ultrasound. The trial does not establish which exercise builds more maximal strength or how trained athletes would respond. Similar results in this small sample leave uncertainty about smaller differences.

This article is based on the published abstract. The journal full text is paywalled and was not reviewed.

Sources (1)

This is news reporting and not medical advice.