News

Nutrition

Soy and whey protein show no significant difference in lean mass gains in small training trials

By Kareem Brown

Published · Updated

A black tub labeled protein beside an open tub and a scoop of pale protein powder on a dark reflective surface
Protein powder in a tub and scoop.

Whey has the better reputation in the lab and soy is the common plant alternative. In training studies lasting six weeks or more, trials comparing the two have mostly found no statistically significant difference in lean mass or strength gains. The trials are small and enroll young adults, so modest differences could still exist.

Pooled trials found no significant gap

A 2018 meta-analysis pooled nine training studies with 266 participants. Five compared whey with soy and four compared soy with other animal proteins. In the five whey-versus-soy studies, changes in strength and lean mass did not differ significantly between the two.

Acute studies suggest whey stimulates muscle protein synthesis more than soy, likely because it has more leucine. Over weeks of lifting, that edge did not appear in strength or lean mass in the pooled data.

A 12-week trial matched for leucine

A 2020 randomized trial enrolled 61 untrained adults, and 48 finished. They lifted three times a week and took either 19 g of whey isolate or 26 g of soy isolate, each containing 2 g of leucine.

The statistical model estimated a 1.54 kg gain in lean mass and clear gains in leg strength across the trial. Neither measure differed significantly between the whey and soy groups.

Vegans on soy matched omnivores on whey

A 2021 study in Sports Medicine put 19 habitual vegans on soy isolate and 19 omnivores on whey. Both groups were brought to 1.6 g of protein per kilogram of body weight daily, then lifted twice a week for 12 weeks.

Leg lean mass rose 1.2 kg in each group. Leg-press strength rose 97 kg in the vegan group and 117 kg in the omnivores, a gap that did not reach statistical significance with 19 people per group.

One newer review leaves the question open

A 2025 meta-analysis of 12 studies and 261 adults aged 18 to 30 found no significant effect of whey or soy supplementation on lean mass. Its authors also reported better bench press and squat performance with whey supplementation and called for larger, higher-quality trials.

The abstract does not say what the whey and soy results were compared against, so this review cannot settle soy versus whey. The head-to-head evidence above stays the basis for this article.

What it means for your shaker

For people already lifting and eating enough protein, either powder fits the evidence. Soy suits anyone avoiding dairy. Whey suits anyone who tolerates it. The better choice is the one you will take consistently.

Total daily protein sat at about 1.6 g per kilogram in the vegan comparison, and results matched. Reaching the protein total is the part those trials controlled.

The trials were small and short, mostly 6 to 12 weeks in untrained young adults. Results may differ for older adults, advanced lifters or people eating less protein.

This is educational material, not medical or dietary advice.

Sources (4)

This is news reporting and not medical advice.