News

Muscle growth

Training at your strongest time of day did not build more strength in older adults

By Kareem Brown

Published · Updated

Analog wall clock above a rack of dumbbells in morning window light
Illustration; not the study materials or participants. Illustration: Optimize Protocols

What the trial tested

Researchers at the University of Basel tested whether older adults gain more from resistance training at the time of day when they are strongest. They randomised 108 adults aged 60 to 80 (41% female, mean age 67) to train at their personal peak time, at their personal trough time, or to keep their usual routine.

Each person was first tested at four times of day, 08:00 to 20:00, on four separate days to find their strongest and weakest times. Training groups then did two supervised resistance sessions and one 30-minute cycling session a week for 12 weeks, including two familiarisation weeks. Adherence was 91% to 93%. It was prospectively registered and Swiss-funded.

Timing made no clear difference

The primary outcome was isometric midthigh pull strength. Peak and trough training differed by 0.06 N per kg (95% CI -0.76 to 0.88). Handgrip strength differed by -0.21 kg per square metre (-0.68 to 0.26), and appendicular lean mass index by 0.03 kg per square metre (-0.09 to 0.15). All intervals span zero.

Fixed training times did not separate either. Comparing morning, noon, afternoon and evening groups gave no consistent pattern, and the contrasts for lean mass stayed within 0.04 kg per square metre. Strength rose from before to after in every group. The data show no clear sign that peak timing added anything.

Strongest times differ, and so does the gap

Before training, peak strength most often fell in the afternoon (32%) or evening (33%), and the trough at noon (40%) or in the morning (29%). Average daily variation was about 11%, but individuals ranged from 1% to 34%. Mean midthigh pull strength was 25.9 N per kg at peak times and 23.3 N per kg at trough times.

Limits that matter

Peak and trough times came from a single four-day profile, so they are estimates. Participants were healthy and independent, and the authors say results may not apply to frail or sarcopenic people. The trial was powered for a moderate difference, so small effects could be missed. The lean-mass scan has its own measurement error.

Dropout was higher in the peak group (14%) than in the trough and control groups (5% each), and 8 of the 11 peak-group dropouts were women. Dropout in the fixed-time groups ranged from 0% in the morning group to 29% in the afternoon group. The sex split was uneven across arms. No serious adverse events were related to training.

What it adds

The authors conclude that older adults can schedule resistance training across the day without losing muscular adaptations, which may help people stick with a routine. The trial tested healthy adults over 10 weeks of progressive training and did not test other populations or longer programmes. One author reports consulting fees unrelated to this work, and the others report no conflicts.

Sources (1)

This is news reporting and not medical advice.