News

Nutrition

In 108 older adults, both diet groups gained muscle with lifting. The omnivores ate more protein

By Kareem Brown

Published · Updated

The IMPACT randomized trial enrolled 108 adults aged 55 and over. Both the lacto-ovo vegetarian and omnivorous groups gained appendicular lean mass during 12 weeks of resistance training. The omnivorous group ate more protein and had a higher average gain. Protein intake differed between the groups.

Who took part and what they did

Participants had a median age of 66, 58% were women, and their BMI was 25.7. They were randomized to lacto-ovo vegetarian or omnivorous diet counseling. Both groups trained with resistance exercise three times a week for 12 weeks.

Everyone aimed for at least 1.2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight each day. The vegetarian group targeted at least 60% plant protein; the omnivorous group targeted at least 60% animal protein. Participants chose their own foods.

The omnivorous group ate more protein

The vegetarian group consumed 1.24 g/kg/day, with 76% of protein from plants. The omnivorous group consumed 1.58 g/kg/day, with 67% from animal sources. The reported difference was -0.33 g/kg/day, with a 95% confidence interval from -0.49 to -0.17. Noninferiority for protein intake was not established.

Protein intake differed between the groups, so the trial compares two diets at different protein intakes. Protein source and amount varied together, which limits what the muscle results say about plant versus animal protein.

Muscle gains and the noninferiority result

DXA measurements showed appendicular lean mass increased by 0.38 kg in the vegetarian group, with a confidence interval from 0.12 to 0.64 kg and P=0.004. The omnivorous group gained 0.66 kg, with a confidence interval from 0.40 to 0.93 kg and P<0.001.

The reported between-group difference was -0.33 kg, with a 95% confidence interval from -0.69 to 0.03 kg. Vegetarian noninferiority was not established against the 0.25 kg margin. The interval spans zero and differences exceeding that margin, limiting what this trial can establish about the gap.

Strength and chair stands improved in both groups

Leg press strength and chair stand performance improved significantly in both groups, and the abstract reports no differences between them.

So what

For older adults choosing a lacto-ovo vegetarian diet, this trial shows muscle gains are achievable alongside regular resistance training and a protein target. Pay attention to total daily protein: the vegetarian group averaged 1.24 g/kg/day, while the omnivorous group reached 1.58 g/kg/day.

Read OP’s coverage of soy versus whey in small training trials and protein per meal.

The limits of this abstract

This was a 12-week trial in volunteers who chose their own foods. The trial tested a lacto-ovo vegetarian diet, which includes eggs and dairy.

This report is based on the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition abstract. We have not reviewed the full paper. The authors report no conflicts of interest, and funding details have not been verified here.

This article provides educational reporting. For personal medical or dietary advice, consult a qualified health professional.

Sources (2)

This is news reporting and not medical advice.